French Parliament Repeals Ban on Renting Energy-Inefficient Homes at Far-Right Initiative
France's National Assembly has voted in favor of a far-right initiative to overturn the gradual ban on renting poorly insulated properties, known as 'passoires thermiques'.
- The National Assembly approved the repeal of energy performance diagnostic (DPE) restrictions by a narrow margin of 108 votes to 102.
- The amendment suspends provisions of the 2021 Climate and Resilience Law that barred the rental of properties rated F and G.
- Tenants' rights organizations labeled the decision a 'disaster' and called for a second vote to protect low-income households.
The French National Assembly saw a major shift in housing policy after lawmakers voted on Tuesday in favor of a legislative amendment initiated by the National Rally (RN), repealing the gradual ban on renting properties with poor energy performance ratings, commonly known as "thermal sieves" (passoires thermiques).
Parliamentary Majority Overturns Energy Performance Restrictions
The amendment was narrowly passed by 108 votes in favor to 102 against, driven by a broad mobilization of right-wing and far-right parties, including MPs from the National Rally (RN), the Union of the Right for the Republic (UDR), The Republicans (LR), and a faction of the Horizons group. The amendment aims to roll back provisions of the 2021 Climate and Resilience Law, which introduced a phased prohibition on renting properties that received the lowest ratings in the Energy Performance Diagnostic (DPE).
The vote took place during deliberations on a government bill designed to tackle the country's severe housing crisis. The core provision of the text, adopted by the Senate in July, had sought to ease regulations by allowing landlords of properties rated F and G to continue renting them out under certain conditions, such as committing to renovation works, before the new amendment completely abolished the ban.
Wide Debate Between the Right and the Government
Following the adoption of the amendment, Frédéric Falcon, the National Rally MP behind the proposal, expressed satisfaction over the removal of what he described as highly damaging restrictions that had strained the rental market for years. Falcon hoped the repeal would hold through the remainder of the legislative process, particularly during the joint committee meeting between MPs and senators.
Conversely, circles close to Housing Minister Vincent Jeanbrun (LR), who had issued an unfavorable opinion opposing the amendment, stated that the government respects parliamentary sovereignty while noting that this decision reflects neither the government's stance nor the minister's ambitions. At this stage, the ministerial team gave no indication of seeking a second deliberation.
Warnings over Impacts on Tenants and Low-Income Households
The decision drew sharp criticism from social and environmental organizations. Manuel Domergue, Director of Studies at the Housing Foundation, condemned what he called a victory for climate populism that constitutes a genuine disaster for tenants, urging the government to hold a second vote to rectify the situation.
Meanwhile, Damien Barboza from the "Rénovons" coalition, an alliance advocating for energy retrofits, warned that lawmakers had chosen to side with wealthier property owners, leaving working-class households exposed to high energy bills, winter cold, and extreme summer temperatures. Barboza pointed out that half of the poorly insulated rental properties in France are owned by the wealthiest 30% of households.
Source: CNews





Comments (0)
You must log in to comment on articles.
Log in Sign upBe the first to comment on this article.