Open Letter by French Student Exposes the 'Meritocracy Myth' and Criticizes the Repression of High School Protests
- Student Taho Lansalot-Devaux describes the concept of meritocracy as a 'myth' that legitimizes inherited privileges and conceals social and economic disparities.
- Sharp criticism directed at punitive justice and state institutions for prioritizing blind deterrence and repressing high school protests instead of addressing the root causes of marginalization.
- A call to reject the duality of 'meritocracy and punitive crackdowns', demanding unconditional equality across all segments of society.
In a remarkable stance reflecting mounting tension within educational and youth circles in France, 15-year-old student Taho Lansalot-Devaux has penned a sharp open letter strongly criticizing the official discourse surrounding "merit and meritocracy," arguing that it serves merely as an ideological tool to legitimize privilege and falsify the reality of economic, social, and cultural inequalities inherited from birth.
The Myth of Meritocracy and the Entrenchment of Class Disparities
In his letter, Lansalot-Devaux stressed that French society is constantly portrayed as an even playing field where everyone reaps the fruits of their effort and labor, describing this premise as "the finest myth invented by the dominant classes to sleep with a clear conscience." He explained that this logic grants the affluent the moral right to flaunt their success as a reward for personal virtue, while less fortunate groups are driven to blame themselves and shoulder the responsibility for failure under the pretext of laziness.
The high school student emphasized that the starting point in life is not equal, asking: How can one speak of merit when a person's fate is predetermined based on their postal code, the cultural and financial capital of their parents, and the level of silent social violence imposed on their environment? He argued that meritocracy turns mere luck and chance into a virtue, enshrining injustice as if it were an inevitable destiny.
From False Promises to Judicial Repression
The author also addressed how authorities handle protests and mobilizations by high school students, pointing out that when marginalized groups suffocate under the weight of structural violence and decide to revolt or reject the rules of a game doomed to failure from the start, the state abandons its promises to brandish the sword of deterrence. He denounced what he termed "punitive justice," which has completely abandoned any attempt to understand underlying causes, turning instead into an instrument of retribution and theatrical sentencing to maintain public order—referring to the labeling of high school protests as "urban violence" to justify heightened repression, as well as the controversial detention and arrest conditions of minors, such as those documented at the Bobigny court.
He added that punishing individuals and isolating them behind bars has become the state's ultimate excuse to avoid questioning itself regarding the harsh living conditions it imposes, thereby reducing fundamental political crises and issues into mere transient criminal events to feed the security apparatus.
A Call for Equality and Rejection of Submission
The French student concluded his letter by stressing that rejecting this dual system based on the "illusion of meritocracy and punitive repression" is not a call for chaos or impunity, but rather a genuine demand to put an end to widespread social hypocrisy. He asserted that true emancipation and liberation begin when society refuses to play by these unjust rules that pick winners and punish losers, demanding instead unconditional equality of rights and opportunities for a dignified life for all.
Source: L'Humanité





Comments (0)
You must log in to comment on articles.
Log in Sign upBe the first to comment on this article.