"Bossless Companies? It's a Mirage": Stanford Professor Nir Halevy Sets the Record Straight
While flat organizations and "unbossing" are currently in vogue, Stanford professor Nir Halevy argues that eliminating hierarchy is impossible. Instead, the real challenge lies in repairing broken corporate structures.
- Stanford Graduate School of Business professor Nir Halevy argues that bossless or flat organizations inevitably see hierarchy re-emerge in other forms.
- Hierarchies persist because of human psychological needs for comparison, achievement, predictability, and collective efficiency, though they can also be entrenched by negative forces.
- Broken hierarchies are characterized by hyper-competitiveness, injustice, and instability, affecting about one in four workers in the US and the UK.
- To fix dysfunctional structures, Halevy advocates for a "CPR" approach based on Common value, Pluralism, and Relatedness.
At work, hierarchy has fallen out of favor. According to a study by recruitment firm Robert Walters published in 2024, only 13% of young American professionals still consider traditional hierarchical structures effective, and 57% do not want to become middle managers. Last March, the pharmaceutical giant Bayer congratulated itself on becoming "significantly more horizontal" after halving its management layers and cutting management headcount by two-thirds.
Yet for Nir Halevy, professor of organizational behavior at the Stanford Graduate School of Business, trying to eliminate hierarchy is a dead end. In Level Up: Why Hierarchies Are Broken and How to Fix Them (Basic Venture, October 2026), he demonstrates how hierarchy has resurfaced every time an attempt was made to abolish it, from kibbutzim to Silicon Valley. The root of the problem, he explains to L'Express, is not hierarchy itself, but what he calls "broken hierarchies." Interview.
L’Express: Some dream of bossless companies. You, on the other hand, are more skeptical. Why?
Nir Halevy: It has already been tried! I am thinking of certain Silicon Valley startups organized along horizontal, more egalitarian lines; of kibbutzim, those communities founded in the first half of the 20th century in Palestine and then in Israel by idealistic young immigrants; or even "flat" companies, such as video game publisher Valve, which operates without a boss. Yet every single time, hierarchy creeps back in through the window, one way or another. Valve, for instance, ranks its employees based on peer evaluations, and this ranking is used to justify salary disparities. These failures show that permanently eliminating hierarchy within large groups of people is extraordinarily difficult.
How do you explain this?
First, there are fundamental psychological tendencies, such as our inclination to compare ourselves to others. Imagine a colleague gets promoted faster than you, is paid better, or is treated differently. Naturally, you will compare yourself to them and question the legitimacy of these gaps. If they seem unjustified, you may find them hard to accept. There is also our need for achievement: individuals want to succeed and advance. That requires a structure that enables them to climb the ladder, which is impossible in a "flat" company. Another need is predictability, to which hierarchy contributes. Finally, hierarchy enhances collective performance: a team where everyone wants to lead struggles to be effective. In the NBA, for example, teams with clearer hierarchies—both in terms of playing time and salaries—win more games over the course of a season.
Alongside these "positive" explanations, other, negative forces sustain hierarchies. Certain ideologies claim that specific groups of the population are inferior to others and should remain so. Such a worldview can reinforce hierarchies and make them harder to challenge, portraying them as rooted in morally legitimate principles and aligned with "nature." Added to this is a form of inertia: both those with power and those without adopt behaviors that cement the established order, as the former tend to take more initiative than the latter. These behaviors reinforce one another and ultimately freeze existing hierarchical structures in place. Finally, there are the "bad actors"—often dominant individuals who resort to intimidation and coercion to preserve their standing. In Australia, many medical students in Sydney and Melbourne reported in a study undergoing "teaching by humiliation."
What distinguishes a healthy hierarchy from a "broken" hierarchy, to use your term?
Broken hierarchies are defined by three characteristics: they are ultra-competitive, unjust, and unstable. In an ultra-competitive hierarchy, the struggle for resources, opportunities, and recognition is constant and ruthless. Blows come from colleagues themselves, fostering an environment rife with stress, feelings of threat, and psychological insecurity. It can even devolve into sabotage: a colleague withholding assistance when they could easily help, such as keeping crucial information to themselves.
In the United States and the United Kingdom, roughly one in four people currently works in an organization with a broken hierarchy.
Nir Halevy
The second characteristic is injustice. This can manifest as what I call distributive injustice: an employee deserves a promotion, but their manager prefers to give it to their nephew. There is also procedural injustice: superiors making arbitrary decisions without justifying or explaining them to their employees. Finally, there is interactional injustice: an employee experiences rudeness, harassment, or abusive and humiliating behavior. When these injustices are combined with hyper-competitiveness, you feel under attack not only from above, from your superiors, but from all sides, particularly your peers. This can be deeply destabilizing. The third characteristic is instability. The company struggles to retain its staff, experiencing continuous turnover: promotions, demotions, and departures follow one another rapidly or unpredictably.
According to data we collected this year, roughly one in four people in the United States and the United Kingdom currently works in an organization with a broken hierarchy.
Economists frequently praise the virtues of competition. At what point should organizations become wary of it internally?
Consider the hours we all spend at work: thousands every year. If employees endure humiliation or other manifestations of hyper-competitiveness throughout that time, their well-being deteriorates, team performance suffers, and the company takes a hit.
When healthy, however, competition can be a powerful motivator. For example, if you are a journalist and one of your colleagues wins a Pulitzer Prize [Editor's note: the most prestigious award in American journalism], it might inspire you to do even better, to launch an investigative series, or to write a book… Positive competition elevates everyone.
How can a manager foster healthy competition?
Stanford, where I teach, has exceptional athletic programs. My student-athletes taught me an essential lesson: to remain positive, competition must be confined to the times and spaces where it is necessary and useful. Take the rowing team: the rivalry to earn one of the eight seats on the boat is intense, but that competition stays on the water. In their dorms, in class, or in the dining hall, solidarity prevails: if one of them is going through a tough time, their teammates rally around them. There is a time for rivalry and a time for mutual support.
Similarly, a manager must alternate between two modes: brainstorming sessions where the clash of ideas is encouraged within a well-defined framework, and moments where judging or disparaging the work of others is strictly off the table. The Navy SEALs, for instance, operate in a deeply hierarchical manner during missions. But in the debrief room, they remove their rank insignia.
You can also leverage collective incentives: favor team bonuses over individual rewards reserved only for top performers, or introduce shared perks that promote shared experiences.
What are the warning signs of a broken hierarchy, and what does it cost a company?
The clearest visible indicator is high employee turnover: workers who feel miserable leave quickly, and the company struggles to attract new talent. Subjected to significant stress, employees suffer declines in both physical and mental well-being, and absenteeism is typically high.
How do you repair a broken hierarchy?
I propose a framework built on three principles, represented by the acronym CPR: C for common value, P for pluralism, and R for relatedness. The artistic director of The Australian Ballet, David Hallberg, provides a wonderful illustration in how he promoted dancers to the highly coveted rank of principal artist. In December 2023 at the Sydney Opera House, following a performance of Swan Lake, he stepped onto the stage to announce the promotions of Marcus Morelli and Jill Ogai to "principal artist." In an emotional speech delivered before 1,400 audience members, he outlined the exact qualities that justified the decision.
A faux meritocracy breeds anger and resentment among citizens.
Nir Halevy
All three principles were present. First, common value: meritocracy, with transparent, legible standards that both encourage and reassure younger dancers. Second, pluralism: the ceremony demonstrated that through dedication, leadership and advancement responsibilities can be shared among multiple individuals. Finally, relatedness: all the dancers spontaneously rushed to embrace the two promoted colleagues.
Imagine, conversely, your boss announcing your promotion in private behind closed doors. That lack of transparency immediately damages team morale and relationships with colleagues: without clear criteria for the promotion, they are likely to question its legitimacy or wonder why they were overlooked. Research clearly shows that a faux meritocracy breeds anger and resentment among citizens.
Source: L’Express





Comments (0)
You must log in to comment on articles.
Log in Sign upBe the first to comment on this article.