Scientific Study Reveals: Why the Anticipated GTA 6 Is Less Addictive Than Other Games Popular in France
A new scientific scale evaluating video game addiction potential classifies GTA 6 as a moderate risk, debunking widespread misconceptions.
- A new scientific index named 'SHARP-G' assesses addiction potential in video games based on 23 psychological and technical criteria.
- GTA 6 is categorized as a 'moderate' risk alongside Mario Kart, while World of Warcraft and Genshin Impact rank in the very high-risk categories.
- Researchers call for the adoption of an awareness label similar to 'Nutri-Score' on games to help parents in France protect their children.
With millions around the world and across the French public eagerly anticipating the imminent release of the renowned game "Grand Theft Auto VI" (GTA 6), social and educational concerns regarding screen addiction and its impact on youth and adolescents have resurfaced. This issue holds particular significance for households residing in France, where the video game market has exceeded the threshold of €6 billion, and the average age of gamers has climbed from 21 in the early 2000s to nearly 40 today, according to data from the Video Game Publishers Union (SELL).
A New Scientific Scale Dismantles the Myth of Danger
Contrary to common public perception, the GTA franchise—despite the vastness of its virtual world and its simulation of organized crime—is not the most hazardous game from an addiction standpoint. The French magazine "L'Express" revealed, based on a new research tool under development called "SHARP-G" (Saini-Hodgins Addiction Risk Potential of Games scale), an accurate classification of five of the world's most prominent games, grounded in 23 behavioral and structural criteria.
Researcher Neeraj Saini, from the Addictive Behaviours Laboratory at the University of Calgary and the supervisor of the tool, explains that the true criterion for addiction is not solely linked to the number of hours spent in front of the screen, but rather to the extent to which gaming negatively affects daily, personal, health, and professional life. According to the scale's findings, "GTA" was placed in the "moderate" risk category, given that its core nature is single-player and its pace halts the moment the console or system is turned off, aligning it with widely popular family titles like "Mario Kart" and the sports simulation game "NBA 2K23."
Where Does the Real Danger to Children Lie?
In contrast, other games were categorized in the "very high" risk bracket. Leading the list is the massively multiplayer online role-playing game (MMORPG) "World of Warcraft" (WoW), whose persistent virtual world never stops, even after logging out, generating constant pressure on players not to miss events and to perpetually race to level up their characters. Louis Moutard, an addiction medicine specialist at Châteaubriant Hospital in France, notes that the continuity of the virtual world provides some individuals with an alternative escape from reality, reinforcing pathological attachment.
Similarly, the popular mobile title "Genshin Impact" stood out among the most dangerous; this is driven by its free-to-play model, immediate accessibility at any time via smartphones, and its reliance on randomized reward mechanisms akin to slot machines and lottery tickets, enticing players to spend real money to upgrade their stats and characters. In January 2025, its developer agreed to pay a $20 million financial settlement to the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) following allegations regarding the marketing of randomized draw systems to minors without disclosing real costs.
Calls for an Awareness Label for Families in France
Ever since the World Health Organization recognized "Gaming Disorder" as an official condition in 2019, calls aimed at protecting consumers and young people have steadily grown. In this context, Daria Kuss, a researcher at Nottingham Trent University and co-developer of the "SHARP-G" index, is pushing for mandatory labeling detailing addictive properties on game packaging and digital platforms, complementing the existing Pan-European Game Information (PEGI) age-rating system.
This initiative, reminiscent of the nutritional "Nutri-Score" label prevalent in France, aims to empower parents and resident communities to understand the psychological mechanics embedded within their children's games, helping them regulate usage without depriving them of balanced entertainment.
Source: L’Express





Comments (0)
You must log in to comment on articles.
Log in Sign upBe the first to comment on this article.